There's two sides to every story Spart.  I have *never* pulled scat when the situation didn't warrant it.  TRx can bitch about wanting a good grunt fight but when they're OSing our AMSes and spamming plasma on the stairs that doesn't tell me they want to fight at all.  At that point I'm going to pull scat.  I can kill anyone just fine with a JH, I don't need a MAX to kill anything, but when we're facing combined MAX/grunt forces significantly larger than our number then we're going to need combined MAX/grunt forces ourselves to achieve our objective. 

     I personally feel you've lost sight of the "fighting to turn sh*t blue and keep it that way" focus of 1CMM, instead of just farming.  An overly large (IMO) percentage of your time is spent whoring up some tower or an interlink while the rest of us try and resecure bases and hold hacks.  The NC have been given a great tool for doing exactly that, the Scatmax.  The JH is a 1v1 weapon, its lack of range makes it significantly less useful than MCG/lasher in a mult vs. multi situation as everyone can't be close to the opposition at the same time and have clear LOS to the target.  The Scatmax is a great way of overcoming that limitation.  When we had 5 guys and pulled 4 scats at Marduk against ~10 AC and friends and prevailed, it was just doing what we had to do to win.  They can bitch and cry on the PS forums all they want, it won't change how I play, and neither will you.  I played for over a year with MA only and did a damn fine job of it, and if I want to go straight up HA and MAX at this point I'll do just that, and I've got 2 fingers in the air for anyone who wants to tell me different.

   All this bitching is only coming because they are LOSING to us.  If we weren't using maxes they'd be bitching about something else.  I don't see AC and DT putting away their spamtastic lashers in interlinks while fighting us, even though that weapon is basically "I Win" mode there.  I don't see TRx shying away from using focused fire from multiple MCGs, even though that weapon is godly at that.  We've been given a tool to use to compete against those things, and I'm going to use it.

   If you call me out in a public forum you're going to get a response in the same place.  If you want to take this to the private forums now that's fine, if not that's fine to.